More Trouble In Mind Dept.

This serves as a good follow-up to my earlier post about the misuse of sexual violence in fiction:

The Bigger Picture: What happens when we find The Line as viewers? -

... at the age of 41, at about 94 minutes into "The Divide," I reached a breaking point, and I realized that I am pretty much incapable of sitting through one more cheap, pointless, exploitative rape in a movie.

I haven't seen The Divide (as I type this it's trending at 19% on Rotten Tomatoes, make of that what you will), but I have seen The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and Irreversible, the latter of which I discussed specifically in my previous post and the former of which I feel roughly the same way he does about.

Again, it's not the presence of sexual violence in a story that bothers me, but the thoughtless way it's used so much of the time. It's too often used as shorthand to make a character a monster, or make a setting that much bleaker, or do something else other than address the subject of sexual violence itself. It is, as Drew says in the quoted piece, button-pushing, or a stacking of the deck, and that cheapens our understanding of it.

People have asked me, isn't this a backing-away from the idea that we need to confront the worst in ourselves through our art? I thought about it, and the answer I came up with was: It all depends on how you go about doing it and to what end, doesn't it? It's one thing to write Last Exit to Brooklyn as a reflection of the world you were surrounded by since you were a child, and another entirely to put a rape scene into a film as a way to make someone all the more of an irredeemable skunk.

A while back I was reading a historical manga series where there was a great deal of this sort of "atmosphere". It got numbing after a while, and soon it started to have the wrong effect: I started thinking more about the creators than I did about the characters. At some point I bailed for less compulsively ugly territory. I don't feel like I missed out on a great deal.

And at this point I'm not rushing out to see The Divide, either. A shame, because when I heard the basic premise described I had the feeling it might be a pretty good little sleeper. But I have the bad feeling I know too much about it now to want to bother.

Tags: books  controversy  literature  movies  writing 

comments powered by Disqus

About This Page

This page contains a single entry by Serdar Yegulalp in the category Uncategorized / General, published on 2012/01/20 10:05.

See all entries for January 2012.

See all entries in 2012.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

My Books

Out Now

Previously Released

More about my books

Search This Site